The Capsule Saga Comes to an End – Swiss Federal Tribunal Denies Trademark Protection to Nespresso Capsules

Your contact

The Swiss Federal Tribunal has ruled that the shape of the Nespresso capsules is technically necessary and that Nestlé’s 3D trademark shall therefore be cancelled (decision 4A_61/2021 of 7 September 2021).

The decision of the Swiss Federal Tribunal is a milestone in the trademark infringement proceedings initiated by Nestlé against Ethical Coffee Company (“ECC”), which had launched biodegradable coffee capsules compatible with the Nespresso coffee machine system.

For the past ten years, Nestlé argued that ECC infringed its 3D trademark for Nespresso capsules and that ECC should thus be prohibited from commercializing its compatible capsules. ECC countered that it did not commit any trademark infringement since the shape of the Nespresso capsule was technically necessary when using the Nespresso system and that Nestlé’s 3D trademark was therefore null and void.

In its decision on the merits, the Cantonal Court of Vaud notably examined whether Nestlé’s competitors had any alternative solutions that were “reasonably” available to them i.e., from which they would not endure any disadvantages compared to the Nespresso capsule. According to the Court, only capsules compatible with the Nespresso system could be retained in the assessment. Also, capsules that presented disadvantages e.g., due to a less optimal shape, were deemed “reasonable” if they provided advantages to the consumer e.g., a more advantageous ecological impact. Therefore, the Cantonal Court held that the shape of the 3D trademark was not technically necessary. Nonetheless, the Court ruled in favour of ECC, holding that the 3D trademark had a common shape, and that said shape could only be registered as trademark if it had established itself as a such through use – which Nestlé failed to prove, according to the Cantonal Court.

With its decision of 7 September 2021, the Swiss Federal Tribunal confirmed the decision of the Cantonal Court, while criticizing the underlying assessment on two aspects. First, even minor additional costs represent a disadvantage in the examination of reasonable alternative solutions. Competitors do not have to put up with less efficient alternatives. Second, the capsules must be sufficiently distinguishable from the Nespresso capsules, in the mind of the consumer, for them to be reasonable alternatives. Upon examination of the Federal Tribunal, no alternative capsule presented in the proceedings could be deemed reasonable. Therefore, the Federal Tribunal held that Nestlé’s 3D trademark was technically necessary and should thus be cancelled because null and void.


Swiss trademark P-486889 (3D mark of the Nespresso capsules)

Resonating with one of its earlier decisions (decision 4A_36/2012 of 26 June 2021), the Federal Tribunal also recalled that shapes that incorporate a technical solution – such as the Nespresso capsule – must remain freely available and should avoid being granted a “perpetual monopoly through trademark law”, since the legislator wanted to give inventors of a technical solution a time-limited advantage (recover their investment), before authorizing free competition at the end of this protection.

Share post

most read


MLL Legal

MLL Legal is one of the leading law firms in Switzerland with offices in Zurich, Geneva, Zug, Lausanne, London and Madrid. We advise our clients in all areas of business law and stand out in particular for our first-class industry expertise in technical-innovative specialist areas, but also in regulated industries.

MLL Meyerlustenberger Lachenal Froriep


Much is still unclear in relation to liability questions around AI tools.

Read our latest post about “Liability during the Lifecycle of an AI Tool” and download our white paper.

Show article.

Our Story

MLL Legal is a leading Swiss law firm with a history that dates back to 1885. The firm has grown both organically and by means of strategic mergers, the latest of which took place on 1st July 2021 between Meyerlustenberger Lachenal and FRORIEP.

The merger establishes MLL Legal, a combined new entity as one of the largest commercial law firms in Switzerland with 150 lawyers in four offices in Switzerland and two offices abroad, in London and Madrid serving clients seeking Swiss law advice.

Our firm has a strong international profile and brings together recognised leadership and expertise in all areas of law affecting commerce today, with a focus on high-tech, innovative and regulated sectors. 

About us


Click here for our latest publications


Read all our legal updates on the impact of COVID-19 for businesses.

COVID-19 Information

Job openings

Looking for a new challenge?

Our talented and ambitious teams are motivated by a common vision to succeed. We value open and straightforward communication accross all levels of the organisation in a supportive working environment.

Job openings

Firm News

Click here for our latest firm news.

Our Team

The regulatory and technological landscape continually require businesses to adapt and evolve.
Our 150+ lawyers are continuously innovating and striving for improvement in everything they do. We embrace new ideas and technologies, combining our wealth of expertise with creative thinking and diligence. With our hands-on approach, we implement viable solutions for the most complex legal challenges.

Our Team.

LexCast – the podcast series by MLL NexGen

Smart legal education on the go. The LexCast hosted by MLL NexGen provides legal insights in a short format that allows listeners to educate themselves on and about legal issues wherever they are and whenever they find the time.

Listen to our podcast series – stay tuned.

MLL Legal on Social Media

Follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter und Instagram.